Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Nov 19, 2026
Some filters need Pro. Your other filters still apply. View Pro
Live pricing, refreshed
How does this compare? View Island Park 11558 rent trends
History follows your bedroom selection. Current rent limits and move-in dates do not change past averages.
Last 15 days
Rental revenue model
We follow each unit's listing activity at this building every day. When a unit stops being listed, we assume it leased at its last listed rent, adjusted for any advertised move-in special. Revenue is the sum of those assumed lease rents across the building's occupied units.
These are research estimates, not financial statements from the operator. Confidence: observed data only.
Observed Lease Revenue
$15K/mo
from 3 tracked leases; not enough coverage yet for a whole-building estimate
Effective Rent on New Leases
$5,021
vs $5,273 current asking ($252 negotiation gap)
See which units leased, when they left the market, and the rent they leased at.
Unlock with ProNegotiation Leverage Score (0-100)
Based on 5 observable signals from the property's listing data:
All signals come directly from the property's own listings. Occupancy and building size appear only in the Estimated Building Revenue section, and only when the building size is stated by the property or our unit-level observation history is deep enough to model it.
Listed Units
18
Good availability
15 floor plans
Move-in Specials
0
No active promotions
Negotiation Leverage
Some signals suggest room to negotiate, especially if you can be flexible on move-in date.
No listed units match these filters. Clear a feature below or remove a filter above to see more units.
Select a unit to see its price history and link to the rental site.
Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Nov 19, 2026
Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Oct 23, 2026
Published monthly total · 14 months
Available: Oct 27, 2026
Published monthly total · 12 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
Published monthly total · 12 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
Published monthly total · 10 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
Published monthly total · 15 months
Available: Dec 4, 2026
Published monthly total · 10 months
Available: Oct 15, 2026
| Unit | Floor Plan | Listed | Details | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1407 | | 1bd / 1ba | 1,280 | $4,431 Published monthly total · 15 months | $3.46 | Nov 19, 2026 | Pro | |
| 710 | | 1bd / 1ba | 1,280 | $4,446 Published monthly total · 15 months | $3.47 | Oct 23, 2026 | Pro | Down $35 since Oct 12 |
| 704 | | 1bd / 1ba | 1,280 | $4,476 Published monthly total · 14 months | $3.50 | Oct 27, 2026 | Pro | |
| 305 | | 2bd / 2ba | 1,267 | $4,616 Published monthly total · 12 months | $3.64 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
| 209 | | 1bd / 1.5ba | 1,132 | $4,686 Published monthly total · 15 months | $4.14 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
| 203 | | 1bd / 1ba | 1,024 | $4,696 Published monthly total · 15 months | $4.59 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
| 903 | | 2bd / 2ba | 1,480 | $4,751 Published monthly total · 12 months | $3.21 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
| 602 | | 3bd / 2ba | 1,358 | $5,266 Published monthly total · 10 months | $3.88 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
| 1102 | | 3bd / 2ba | 1,358 | $5,391 Published monthly total · 15 months | $3.97 | Dec 4, 2026 | Pro | |
| 1209 | | 3bd / 2ba | 1,496 | $5,471 Published monthly total · 10 months | $3.66 | Oct 15, 2026 | Pro | |
Parking, wellness and pet policy details for this building are available to Pro members: garage type and any monthly fee, bike storage, EV charging, amenities such as a sauna or cold plunge, and stated pet rent and weight limits.
Unlock with ProFreight line 2,316 ft away · 60 trains/day
City Club
Real tips from people who lived at this property: what leasing and daily living are actually like, plus the gate, parking, and entry codes you only learn once you move in. See all Island Park, NY notes
See how rent prices are changing in Island Park 11558 and across Island Park, NY.
Tell us where you're moving. We'll find apartments nearby and start tracking real prices for you, free.
Request Your City$7.99/month · Cancel anytime
Secure checkout. Cancel anytime.
Get weekly rent reports delivered free. Price drops, new units, and the best deals we found this week.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.